PUEBLOListingsListings / Newark / 131-133 Underwood StChecked Nov 12, 2026Start 2 weeks free

131-133 Underwood St

Newark, NJ 07106For sale
The lot meets the size for 4 homes. The town has the last word.
Asking price
$557,000
last sold $165,000, Jul 29, 2004
The lot meets the size for
4 homes
C-1 · 41:5-3-3/-4; 41:5-3-6 low-rise multifamily 375 sq ft per home
Three or more homes go to the Planning Board for site plan review. The town's zoning office and boards have the last word.
38×100 ft · 3,760 sq ft
1 home stands today, built 1920
Lot price per home
$139,250
$93 per buildable sq ft
6,016 sq ft allowed
HUD rent, all homes
$9,720/mo
3-bedroom HUD fair market rent, $2,430 per home
HUD Small Area FMR FY2026 · ZIP 07106 · Newark, NJ HUD Metro FMR Area
The other three could bring about
$7,290/mo
if you live in one home. HUD rent, not a quote.
HUD Small Area FMR FY2026 · ZIP 07106 · Newark, NJ HUD Metro FMR Area

The zoning case

The lot meets the size for 4 homes in zone C-1. Here is each test from the town's code, and what is left to build on.

  • ✓Lot area4 homes need 3,500 sq ft3,760 sq ft · 260 to spare
  • ✓Lot width4 homes need 35 ft38 ft · 3 to spare
  • ·Heightthe most the zone allows4 floors · 48 ft
  • ·Building coverage40% of the lot1,504 sq ft footprint
  • ·Yardsfront 6 ft · rear 30 ft · sides 6 ft together2,022 sq ft inside the yards
  • =Buildable floor areathe smaller footprint × 4 floors6,016 sq ft
  • !Parking0.5 off-street space per home · Newark Code Table 7-1, §41:7-2-6 (2- to 4-family: 0.5 spaces per unit)2 spaces
  • !Approvalthree or more homes go to the Planning Board for site plan reviewPlanning Board

41:5-3-3/-4; 41:5-3-6 low-rise multifamily 375 sq ft per home · read Nov 11, 2026 · lot size: NJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026, recorded as 37.6X100 R4 1.1. Read the town's code
Sketches, not plans. The zoning officer has the last word.

Run it with your own numbers

Type your own build cost and what a new home here sells for. The sums happen in your browser only, and nothing is saved or sent.

Square feet to build for these homes: 5,647. The zoning allows up to 6,016 sq ft on this lot.

The build cost and the sale price are yours to set. The starting figures here are Pueblo's assumptions, not quotes.

Yield est. 6.2% = gross rent ÷ (asking price + estimated build cost): $116,640 a year ÷ ($557,000 + $1,317,529). The build cost is $1,072,941 to build, $214,588 for design, permits and carry, and $30,000 to take down the old house. The build figure starts from ICC Building Valuation Data (April 2026) × 1.08 for New Jersey. These are Pueblo's starting assumptions, not a quote, and you can change each one.

What sells nearby

New buildings sold in Newark · built 2020 or later

AddressLotBuiltSoldPrice
225 S 9th St25X1002024Dec 11, 2024$810,000
35-37 West End Ave37.6X1002022Dec 2, 2024$370,000
825 S 18th St25X1002024Aug 12, 2024$775,000
323 S 19th St28X1002024Jun 19, 2024$770,000
762 S 14th St28X1002024Jun 14, 2024$800,000
792 S 14th25X1002022May 20, 2024$684,000
223 S 10th St25X1002023Mar 25, 2024$640,000
120 Badger Ave25X1052024Feb 29, 2024$725,000
496--498 S 18th St3333SF 33.33X1002024Feb 16, 2024$850,000
38 Palm St35X1002024Jan 17, 2024$175,000
174 Scheerer Ave35X1002023Oct 23, 2023$745,000
171-173 Shephard Ave37.6X1002023Oct 23, 2023$745,000
Median$745,000

Older houses on lots 45 ft wide or more · what the land trades for

AddressLotBuiltSoldPrice
121-123 Norman Rd47.11X1001910Jan 24, 2026$550,000
205-207- Eastern Pkway55X1201949Jan 2, 2025$650,000
328-330 Kerrigan Blvd45 X 911925Dec 4, 2024$420,000
140-144 Montrose St66.1X1001930Nov 8, 2024$480,000
89-93 Boylan St77X491957Oct 31, 2024$259,000
305-307 Kerrigan Blvd47X1201932Oct 23, 2024$730,000
121-123 Oakland Terr60 X 91.11927Sep 9, 2024$370,000
23-25 Oakland Terr50X1001909Jul 11, 2024$625,000
Median$515,000

Recorded deeds in the NJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026; latest deed in that file is Jan 24, 2026. Class 2 (one to four family). The tax list does not say how many homes each building holds.

Rent

Rent: now vs. new homes

Earns now
Current rent not stated
The listing does not say what the building rents for today.
New homes could earn
$9,720 a month (HUD, est.)
4 homes at the HUD fair market rent for ZIP 07106. Not a quote.
Measure1 bed2 bed3 bedSource
HUD fair market rent, ZIP 07106$1,600$1,930$2,430FY2026
Median rent paid, this census tract$1,490 all sizesACS 2020–2024

3-bedroom HUD fair market rent, $2,430 per home. HUD sets a ceiling for vouchers; local rents for older units are lower, for example the tract median of $1,490.

HUD Small Area FMR FY2026 · ZIP 07106 · Newark, NJ HUD Metro FMR Area · Census ACS 2020–2024 · tract 002300. Fair market rent is not a quote.

Today's house and taxes

BuiltNJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 20261920NJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026
BuildingNJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 20262-story frameNJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026
Property taxNJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026 · last year billed$5,057 a yearNJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026 · last year billed
Assessed valueland $25,500 + building $107,500 · a tax figure, far under market in Newark · NJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026$133,000land $25,500 + building $107,500 · a tax figure, far under market in Newark · NJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026
Last recorded saleNJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026$165,000 · Jul 29, 2004NJ MOD-IV tax list (NJGIN) · Mar 2, 2026

Price history

DateEventPriceChangeSource
Jul 29, 2004Sold (deed)$165,000NJ MOD-IV
Nov 11, 2026For sale, as seen$557,000+237.6%Homes.com

We record prices only as a listing page or a deed shows them; value estimates are never recorded as prices. This listing page did not show days on market.

Demand and commute Rental demand: High · 7 of 8

Rental vacancy
0.9%
tract · under 3% is tight
Homes rented
45%
tract · renter-occupied
Rent growth
+27.8%
2017–21 to 2020–24
To Manhattan
30 min
via Newark Penn Station · NJ Transit NEC timetable eff 2026-11-15
How the score is built

Vacancy under 3% scores 2, 3–6% scores 1. Renter share 50% or more scores 2, 35–49% scores 1. Rent growth 15% or more scores 2, 5–14% scores 1. Commute 35 min or less scores 2, 36–50 scores 1. Six to eight is high, three to five medium.

Census ACS 2020–2024 · tract 002300, tables B25003, B25004, B25064 · commute: published timetables, read Nov 11, 2026.

See what fits →